Paolo Bacigalupi
Paolo Bacigalupi is HCN's Online Editor.
WIRED Magazine, the cheerleader of the high-tech set has an interesting article in their latest issue on GMO creeping bentgrass.
True to many WIRED stories, “Turf Warrior” starts out with a profile of a high-octane can-of-whup-ass CEO on a mission to take tech to the masses and make gobs of cash in the process.
For him [Jim Hagedorn], the lawn is not the boring domain of suburban dads and little old ladies. It’s a business battlefield where innovation is crucial. When it comes to grass, people worry about watering, maintenance, and weeds, three headaches that genetic engineering - transgenic turf - could dramatically alleviate. “That’s the big kahuna for consumer lawns,” he says. “Solve those three issues and you’re a friggin’ hero!”
WIRED seems to have a fetish for these can-do corporate types. The men with the vision for the future. Unfortunately, the “Former F-16 pilot who collects muscle cars (40 at last count)” (What is he, Clive Cussler?”) is the fearless leader of Scotts-Miracle Grow company, the company that created transgenic grass-seed that (surprise!) blew out of its contained fields in Oregon and turned GMO into an EIS issue.
The WIRED story is odd because it almost feels as if two different people wrote the story: it’s a technology rah-rah love fest, but then slowly — almost unwillingly — it acknowledges just how much of a genie in the bottle an herbicide-resistant bentgrass might be for ecosystems. But even as it acknowledges hazards, it also works to dismiss them:
…Plants with a new, survival-boosting trait gain a competitive advantage that will launch them on a global ecological conquest, potentially disrupting whole ecosystems.
In the case of the Roundup-ready bentgrass, though, such a superweed scenario is probably a stretch. Researchers have found no indication that the transgenic variety has any advantages over its conventional cousin besides its resistance to glyphosate. And the grass can still be killed with other (harsher) herbicides. In other words, Butler says, a clump of Roundup-ready bentgrass along this or that irrigation canal is doing what any clump of grass does: photosynthesizing and keeping the banks from falling into the canal. That’s about it.
HCN covered the creeping bentgrass story last year, and all the high-tech details that should have been in WIRED (I really used to love this magazine): genetic drift, how bentgrass already functions as an invasive in riparian environments, examples of other biotech surprises that have happened, etc. are in High Country News. When did the Luddites start being more thorough on tech than the techies?
In any case, by the end of the story, WIRED has recovered from whatever fever dream worries it might have had about its swashbuckling CEO’s plans for genetically improving the world. Life is an adventure and technology is fun to tinker with! Full speed ahead and damn the torpedoes! They close on this note:
Hagedorn likes to pull out jargon from his days in the Air Force. One of his favorite terms is FEBA - forward edge of the battle area. ScottsMiracle-Gro was in the FEBA in central Oregon, and the company is clearly in the FEBA with its version 2.0 transgenic grass. Hagedorn may have been slowed down by the USDA, but he has no intention of giving up on innovation. “I decide what I’m going after, and I go after it,” he says. “I don’t stop.” Watching grass grow was never so exciting.
I’m excited. Aren’t you?